Monday, February 22, 2010

Critique Questions for Hoax Project Draft 1

Within your groups of three or four, view and discuss the work of each group member.
  1. Which of the two comps seems the most convincing, so far?
  2. Which design / concept seems to hold the most promise, as a whole?
  3. Do the image(s) support the concept in a plausible way?
  4. Why or why not? Technical, photoshop reasons? Photographic reasons? Lighting, scale, focus, etc? Design concerns? Other?
  5. How could either of the two be improved?
  6. Are there positive elements from each that might be combined -- drawing strength from both?
  7. Do you think it will "go viral"? What might help?

No comments:

Post a Comment